Genre: Mystery, Thrillers, Women’s Fiction
Publisher: Bookouture
Publication Date: October 2020
While to most Great Rock Island is a summer-holiday destination, to Evvy and a small group of locals, it is home. Every year, when the cold rolls in carrying storms off the Atlantic, the island reverts to being just theirs for a few months. However, the discovery of an outsider’s body lying on the snow-covered beach shakes the community. Evvy’s own life is plunged into fear and chaos when it comes to the light that Ian, her partner, was the last person to see the victim alive. As questions, suspicions, and gossip mount, Evvy will do whatever it takes to protect her daughter.
The promise of a murder-mystery set to the backdrop of an isolated community where beauty turns to nightmare and tight-knit to claustrophobic had me running to read Everybody Lies by Emily Cavanagh. Sadly, I soon discovered it was more small-town drama and less mystery — specifically that of two families and their twisted lives. Between the lies, the cheating, the drugs, and enough bad decisions between them to sink the entire island, I couldn’t connect or empathize with any of them. The writing itself is not bad, but with no likable characters to keep me invested, I found myself skimming after the forty percent mark, even then only because I had committed to reviewing it.
In the end, I think the main issue was a book not reaching the right hands. A reader looking for a family drama, a story that dwells on the downward spiral of poor choices, and the heartbreaking effects of drugs could like Everybody Lies.
Review copy provided by publisher via NetGalley. Thanks!